data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/868d5/868d589eb2fa143781910a8ee1d98e8067d3f53a" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4198e/4198e14247a5ab79e23cd147ea1921ab17b58afd" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6cae1/6cae19521365dfe5f24fa1102ad0426200c9e96c" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/12746/12746272046d87fe46dcc51d4eda05e44c7a4950" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0c2b2/0c2b2c17ff6d8789e3e24a1d4604888dd4ab5924" alt=""
In a recent blog post, a well-known Christian pastor, writer, and speaker on issues related to sexual intimacy in Christian marriages made some comments that created quite a stir and outrage from many women. In the blog post, the author said a lot of very true and helpful things! But then the author shared a belief and stories around how a Christian wife might help their porn-struggling spouse by being more sexually available to him, rather than refusing sex. The author was careful to say that sex would not “cure” the porn use but could “help.” However, women began to respond to the post to disagree with what the author was saying. The author then began to block response comments on his blog and was demeaning to those who responded with disagreement and those who attempted to share their painful experiences; from all appearances, he did not respond well to this rebuke or their pain. His initial post and all responses are now removed from his Facebook page.
There are so many things wrong and potentially harmful in such guidance or counsel to couples when one party in the relationship is chronically using pornography. I am a specialist in trauma, betrayal trauma and sexual betrayal, and I wish this author had conferred with me or someone like me before making such statements about married sex while one party is regularly consuming pornography. He could have avoided encouraging something that is potentially harmful to a betrayed spouse! In fact, I was part of a group of women who spoke with this author with loving confrontation about a similar issue two years ago. He had the opportunity to know better because brave and loving women shared with him then in the hopes he would hear and learn.
I have conducted research about betrayed women’s experiences. Here is what I know to be true as to the experiences of many women when their loved one uses porn. These women experience anything but being honored or cherished. They feel inadequate and rejected sexually. They often feel shock and shame that their loved one would engage in this behavior. They are often traumatized (70% in my research sample). The betrayed spouse might experience discomfort if and when their loved one attempts to bring sexual behaviors they viewed in their porn use into the marriage bed.
I remember one woman who put it this way “If I tried to have sex with my husband, knowing he was viewing porn regularly, it was like there were hundreds of other women in the bed with us!”
So, while feeling betrayed, less-than, discarded, compared, cheated on- she is also supposed to be sexually available to a man who is being unfaithful to her on a regular basis? To quote this same author, “enough is enough.”
I’ve talked with many women who have attempted exactly what this author suggested, only to find themselves dissociating while attempting to be sexual. Dissociation is a trauma response. They felt traumatized attempting to be sexual with someone who sexually betrayed them! Their bodies, their minds, their SOULS felt traumatized! And this is what this author is suggesting a wife do? This is abusive.
Here is another thing I know. Compulsive porn use is not really about sex. It is used as a vehicle for numbing out, voyeurism, mood-management, novelty seeking, is often compulsive and can become part of addictive behavior. Much of today’s pornography includes violent or degrading behavior toward women. It does not reflect Christ-like, person-honoring sexuality. Someone chronically using porn is usually not doing so because of lack of sex in the marriage. Very often, it is the betrayed spouse who is being sexually neglected as their loved one prefers sexual release via porn. More sex (even with your spouse) is not a cure or even helpful for pornography addiction. Connection is the best remedy. Talk. Connect. Emotional intimacy. Not sex. I’d love to hear a pastor say something like “If you are tempted to go to porn, talk to someone about your feelings. Be honest. Share your fears or frustrations about life with your spouse. That can lead to mutual and satisfying (non-exploitive or abusive) sexual intimacy.”
Porn use is not mutual. It is one sided, self-focused, and has no connection to a Christian view of marital sexual intimacy. And yet this Christian author and pastor suggests a wife be “available” as a replacement to porn? A wife is not methadone for their loved one’s porn addiction.
I asked a group of women what they would like to say to a pastor/author who would encourage women to help their loved one heal from compulsive/addicted porn use by being more sexually available - what would they want this pastor to know. These women are now in roles where they encourage and support other women who have been betrayed sexually in their marriages. They are trained, healed leaders. They are Christians. And they are concerned that a pastor would suggest such potentially hurtful/harmful behaviors for women. Here are a few of their comments:
To any author or pastor:
“Stop objectifying women and giving men a pass. When did the Christian community decide women are sexual liaisons put on this earth to satisfy weak-willed men? And how on earth can we have a Christian community be led by men who are so weak they cannot and will not control their sexual impulses?”
“Why weren’t the voices you heard two years ago enough? You don’t have the right to be ignorant anymore.”
“I am not an object to be played with in the bedroom to satisfy a man’s sexual cravings.”
“Used as a tool for their lust – we are blamed for not being available enough – and we are consumed instead of cherished.”
“So, the idea that our marital availability will provide a way out of ‘drug use’ (sex as a drug) is ridiculous/uneducated. We’ve all tried (ad nauseam). If that worked - it would have worked by now. It's like trying to replace meth or cocaine with sexual availability.”
I encourage authors/pastors to read “Your Sexually Addicted Spouse: How Partners Can Cope and Heal” (Steffens & Means, 2009; 2021) to better understand the significant impact of betrayal for spouses/partners and THEN think about advice you offer to betrayed women. Available on Amazon.